|
Preview of ASHG 57th Annual Meeting's
Presidential Symposium: Genes and
Identity |
-Wylie Burke, ASHG President
-
The Presidential Symposium, moderated by Dr.
Burke, will be presented on Friday, October 26,
San Diego Convention Center, Hall H
One of the most striking social consequences of
genetic research has been the exoneration of
wrongfully convicted prison inmates, some of them on
death row, using DNA-based evidence. This evolving
history is an indicator of the broad reach of genome
science. More profoundly, it demonstrates how the
window provided by a new technology can raise
serious questions about a basic social structure, in
this case the criminal justice system. The successes
of the Innocence Project, the nationwide nonprofit
program that has spearheaded the use of genetic
evidence for exoneration, represent a DNA-based
social good. However, a broader exploration of
genetics as a source of identity reveals a more
complex picture. Within the criminal justice system,
access to the benefits of genetic technology are not
uniform; and DNA-based identification also poses
potential harms, with developments such as large
forensic banks and the inclusion of family members
in efforts to identify criminals.
The complexity extends to other ways in which genes
and identity intersect. Many people have embraced
genomic ancestry tests as a means of gaining
insights into their genealogical histories and
ancestral origins. Yet genetics is only one of many
sources of personal identity, and may either
complement or conflict with other ways of
determining who we are. Can our multifaceted genetic
and social identities be reconciled? Will genetics
affect the value or change the meaning of other
sources of identity? There is a need for sustained
public and professional dialogue, and rigorous
research, regarding the interface between knowledge
of genetic variation and prevailing paradigms of
human identity.
This dialogue has particular salience for clinicians
when genetic identity becomes the source for
clinical decision-making, or a means to identify
persons with potentially disabling genetic
conditions. Physicians, healthcare researchers, and
people with disabilities all work from the
standpoint of wanting to do what is in the best
interest of disabled individuals, but the notion of
what actually is “best” is often understood quite
differently among these constituencies. Defining a
disabled person by genotype may have the unintended
consequence of diminishing the individuality and
promise that are also a part of that person’s
identity. Genetic information is a potential source
of powerful new therapeutic insights and
opportunities, but also of questions about how we
define and label people.
This year’s Presidential Symposium will explore the
growing potential for genetics to influence or
assign personal identity, and consider its social
implications. Speakers include Frederick R. Bieber,
MD, Harvard Medical School/Brigham and Women’s
Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts; Justin Brooks, JD, LLM, Director, California Innocence Project at
California Western School of Law, San Diego;
Charmaine D. Royal, PhD, Institute for Genome
Sciences and Policy, Duke University, Durham, North
Carolina; and Paul Miller, JD, School of Law,
University of Washington, Seattle.
TOP OF
PAGE

|
ASHG
Annual Meeting Program Committee Update |
-Elizabeth R. Hauser, Chair, 2007 Program
Committee and Dayna Silberman, Program Coordinator

The ASHG program committee has recently finished its
most complex and challenging task: reviewing and
scoring the submitted abstracts, selecting
presentations, and arranging the invited sessions.
The committee hopes that you will learn from and
enjoy the meeting, which promises to be very
exciting this year. Over 80 ASHG member volunteers
reviewed nearly 3000 abstracts. Each abstract is
independently scored by three expert reviewers. The
highest ranking abstracts are discussed at a meeting
of the program committee in mid-July at the FASEB
campus, six abstracts are chosen for the plenary
session, and 280 abstracts are selected for the 28
contributed platform sessions. It is hard work but
reviewers and program committee members are rewarded
with a confidential sneak peek at the most exciting
research across the spectrum of human genetics.
The program for the Annual Meeting is finalized in
mid-July but it represents a year of work beginning
at the previous year’s meeting. The ASHG staff work
hard to make sure that everything progresses
smoothly. The development of the program for the
Annual Meeting is a lengthy collaborative process.
The chair of the committee assumes responsibility
for the overall coordination of the process
throughout the year and invites the special
symposium speakers.
ASHG members make this program possible. There are
many other important roles that members play,
including:
-
Submitting invited session proposals,
-
Submitting high quality abstracts,
-
Volunteering to serve as a committee member or
an abstract reviewer, and
-
Serving as a moderator on-site at the meeting.
We salute the ASHG volunteers who worked so hard
throughout the year in all of these roles for the
success of this program. We look forward to seeing
you in San Diego!
TOP OF
PAGE
|
Congratulations to the Following ASHG Award
Winners |
Awards will be
presented at the 2007 Annual Meeting
 |
Award for Excellence in Human Genetics Education
Robert Elston, Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine, Cleveland,
Ohio |
| |
|
 |
Curt Stern Award
Jeffrey Murray, University of Iowa Carver College of Medicine, Iowa City |
| |
|
 |
Leadership Award
Walter E. Nance, Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, Virginia |
| |
|
 |
The Peter and Patricia Gruber Foundation’s Gruber Prize
Maynard V. Olson, University of Washington, Seattle |
| |
|
 |
William Allan Award
Arthur L. Beaudet, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas |
TOP OF
PAGE
|
2007
ASHG Meeting At-a-Glance |
Sessions and Trainee Events
Click
here to view
TOP OF
PAGE
|
Look
Forward to Scientific Session Highlights at
the Annual Meeting, including... |
Presidential Address: Who Is Under the
Umbrella – And Why Are We Here?
Wylie Burke, ASHG President, University of
Washington School of Medicine, Seattle
Wednesday, October 24, 1:00 PM–1:30 PM
San Diego
Convention Center, Hall H
“Our Society has expanded remarkably over the
past decade, with a growing diversity in member
interests and disciplinary backgrounds...We need
to be sure our umbrella is big enough to make
room for everyone who shares our vision….Are we
doing enough? Challenges represent the next wave
of opportunity for our Society.”
Special Plenary Symposium: Evolution and
Medicine
Saturday, October 27, 11:00 AM–12:30 PM
San Diego
Convention Center, Hall H
This special symposium, moderated by Drs. Peter
Byers and Diddahally Govindaraju, is designed to
explore the ways in which human evolution, and
the evolution of other organisms such as
infectious agents, shapes the present day
medical environment. The four talks in the
symposium, given by Drs. Michael Bamshad, James
Evans, Lynn Jorde, and David Valle, will address
the role of evolution in medicine from the
perspectives of population biology, ethnic,
variation, and individualized medicine, as well
as society and law.
Trainee Awards Program
For outstanding trainee research in 2007, The
American Society of Human Genetics will present
30 trainee awards at $300 each to semifinalists,
based on abstracts scored by members of the
Program Committee. Of those 30 trainee awardees,
18 finalists (top scorers reviewed by the Awards
Committee) will receive complimentary
registration. These 18 finalists’ presentations
will be evaluated by three reviewers at the
meeting in San Diego. Six winners will be chosen
(one in each category). They will each win an
additional $200, to be presented on Saturday,
October 27, at 2:00 PM in the San Diego
Convention Center, Hall H.
Distinguished Speakers’ Symposium: The Bridge
Between Research and Practice
Saturday, October 27, 3:15 PM–5:15 PM
San Diego
Convention Center, Hall H
Dr. Elizabeth Hauser, chair of the 2007 program
committee, will moderate this unique symposium
featuring Drs. Priya Kishnani, Andrew Feinberg,
and Judith Cho, and focusing on the challenges
of drawing connections between research findings
and wider application to clinical studies. Their
presentations will provide exciting examples of
research bridging discovery, translation, and
clinical implementation.
Check
online for complete information about the 2007
ASHG meeting.
Abstract Search and Itinerary Planner will be
available online after September 6.
TOP OF
PAGE
|
Calling all Counselors and
Clinicians! |
ASHG will host Curbstone Consult sessions again this
year at the Annual Meeting
San Diego Convention Center, Room 24B
Wednesday, October 24, 11:30–1:00 PM
Friday, October 26, 12:00–1:30 PM
Curbstone Consults provides an opportunity for
genetic counselors and clinicians to present cases
to a group of expert clinical geneticists. Cases may
be diagnostic dilemmas, or consultation may be
sought for confirmation of a suspected diagnosis.
The discussion is not limited to the designated
experts as each of you has a unique expertise and we
welcome suggestions and comments by all
participants.
To allow many experts and registrants to participate
in the discussion, the presentation format is as
follows: Each case will be presented using
PowerPoint slides, with a limit of six slides and 3
minutes per presentation. Discussion will follow by
the expert panel and the audience. Audience
participation is encouraged. Discussion will be
limited to 5 minutes, allowing a minimum of 11 cases
to be reviewed in each 90 minute session. Please
load your case into the computer before the session
begins and label each file with the presenter’s
name.
Schedule:
| Wednesday,
11:30 AM–1:00 PM |
Area of special interest |
| Sharon Plon |
cancer genetics |
| Kate Nathanson |
cancer genetics |
| Marilyn Jones |
dysmorphology, clefting |
| Alain Verloes |
dysmorphology |
| Karen Gripp |
dysmorphology |
| Bill Dobyns |
brain malformations |
| Pedro Sanchez |
LDDB, Possum database |
| Friday, 11:30
PM–1:00 PM |
Area of special interest |
| Karen Gripp |
dysmorphology |
| Bill Dobyns |
brain malformations |
| Pedro Sanchez |
LDDB, Possum database |
| Han Brunner |
dysmorphology, hearing loss |
| Anne Slavotinek |
dysmorphology, diaphragmatic
hernia |
| David Rimoin |
skeletal dysplasia |
| Stephen Kahler
|
metabolic disorders |
| Cyndy Curry |
dysmorphology |
| Lynne Bird |
dysmorphology |
Curbstone Consults is organized and moderated by
Karen Gripp.
TOP OF
PAGE
|
Special Events for Trainees
at the Annual Meeting |
While we are certain you will find many talks and
posters to fill your days at the meeting, if you are
a graduate student or a postdoc, there are a number
of other events planned throughout the meeting to
provide opportunities for networking, career
exploration and professional development. Unless
otherwise noted, all events are at the San Diego
Convention Center.
Networking
Maybe you have heard that, in real estate, it’s all
about “location, location, location.” Often in
science and other professions, career opportunities
(and even your next collaboration) are about
networking, networking, networking. With this in
mind, the ASHG meeting offers several different
opportunities for networking among members at all
stages of their careers.
*Opening Mixer: Tuesday, October 23, 7pm-10
pm, San Diego Marriott & Marina: Light food and cash
bar available for attendees to mix and mingle before
the actual commencement of scientific talks.
*Mentor-Trainee Luncheon: Wednesday, October
24, 11:30 pm-1 pm. This event provides a wonderful
opportunity for students in the field of human
genetics to sit and chat informally with senior
members of the Society about career goals,
achievements, training programs, and many other
career options within the various disciplines of
genetics. Lunch tickets cost $15 and
pre-registration is required.
*Career Networking Session: Wednesday,
October 24, 8 pm-10pm: Desserts and beverage tickets
available for all pre-registrants. If you are
thinking about what steps you might take toward your
next career goal—be it academic science or patent
law—this session will provide opportunities to speak
with experts and other trainees interested in
similar fields.
Check out this site for more information.
*Closing Event: Saturday, October 27, 7
pm-11pm, San Diego Natural History Museum. This
special social event will feature a special viewing
of the Dead Sea Scrolls. ASHG attendees will have
private access to this exhibit, as well as the rest
of the museum (including the rooftop deck). This is
the perfect opportunity to relax and continue
discussions that began earlier in the week with
mentors and colleagues. Pre-registration is required
and tickets will NOT be available for sale at
the meeting.
Career Evaluation
Are you having doubts about your next steps? Are you
ready to apply for a post-doc, your first academic
position or another career altogether? Plenty of
opportunities are available for you and your
colleagues struggling with these and similar
questions. These resources are available for you to
help on your path to the next step in your career.
*FASEB Career Corner: Available throughout
the ASHG meeting. Career development experts from
FASEB will have a booth in the main lobby of the San
Diego Convention Center and will be available
throughout the meeting to review résumés and
curriculum vitas, complete mock job interviews, and
discuss the various steps involved in your job
search. Bring a copy of your resume,
your career development plan or just a general
list of questions for these experts to assist you.
*Job Fair Meet & Greet: Wednesday, October
24, 6 pm-8 pm. Potential employers and job-seekers
can meet in this informal setting to hold brief
face-to-face interviews. Employers can post
advertisements beforehand using the FASEB Web site,
or bring an advertisement with them for trainees to
view on job boards throughout the meeting.
Professional Development
*Mock Study Section: Saturday, October 27,
12:30 pm-2 pm. Have you ever wondered what happens
after you or your advisor drop off your grant at the
FedEx box? This is your chance to find out. Grant
review experts from the National Institutes of
Health will provide an opportunity to participate in
a mock study section over lunch. Lunch tickets are
$15 and pre-registration is required.
*Career Networking Session: Wednesday,
October 24, 8 pm-10 pm. This session will begin with
a talk by Dr. Joann Boughman on negotiating skills
for graduate students and trainees. Following this
keynote speaker, ASHG trainees can hear from a
variety of different individuals on a panel
discussing different tips on entering a variety of
career paths. From 9:00 pm until 10:00 pm, a
networking reception will allow all trainees to
interact with individuals from a variety of careers
over cocktails and dessert. Attendance is limited to
250 individuals. Pre-registration is required.
More information including registration is available
online.
TOP OF
PAGE
|
MARC Minority Travel Award
Program Providing Funds to Attend the ASHG
Meeting in San Diego |
For United States citizens or those who have
permanent resident status in the United States.
Successful applicants will be reimbursed up to $1450
in meeting-related travel expenses including the
meeting registration fee. The travel award
recipients will be selected based on need and the
quality of scientific abstracts. Awardees will be
recognized during the ASHG Awards Presentation in
San Diego.
Please visit the
ASHG meeting Web site for more information and
to complete the application form.
Important: the new deadline for receipt of
applications is September 17.

Early Meeting Registration Deadline:
September 7
Housing Deadline: September 14
-Joann Boughman, ASHG Executive Vice President
As we have reported, the Genetic Information
Nondiscrimination Act (GINA) passed the United
States House of Representatives 420-3 on April 25,
which was DNA Day! The final steps include this
version of the bill going back to the Senate that
has passed similar bills unanimously in two previous
Congressional sessions. We were very hopeful, but
ran into a snag in the Senate passage that occurs
when the Senate is trying to obtain unanimous
consent on a piece of legislation. Any one Senator
(or as many as wish) may put a “hold” on a bill to
stop the unanimous consent process. While a few
Senators put temporary holds on the bill, it is Dr.
Tom Coburn, senator from Oklahoma, who has kept the
bill from moving for a few weeks now.
On July 26, the Genetic Alliance held its annual
“Genetics on the Hill” day and every senator’s
office was visited. We spoke at length with Dr.
Coburn’s staff, and they articulated a few issues
that remain problematic for the senator. In an
August 1 public meeting, Dr. Coburn stated that he
currently had holds on 87 pieces of legislation. The
Coalition for Genetic Fairness continues to speak
with the appropriate staff members in the offices of
Senators Kennedy, Enzi, and Snowe (leaders in this
process on GINA), as well as to continue talking
with Dr. Coburn and staff.
We remain hopeful that any remaining issues (that
many of us thought had been appropriately managed in
previous iterations of the legislation and in the
several Committee hearings in the House) can be
dealt with expeditiously and the unanimous consent
process may resume quickly after the August break.
If there are changes, we will go back to the House
and get the revised bill passed. THEN, it can be
sent to the president, who has indicated by way of
an SAP (Statement of Administration Policy) that he
wished to receive the bill so he can sign it into
law.
TOP OF
PAGE
|
Recognizing ASHG's Global
Membership |
Proposed changes to ASHG Bylaws
The ASHG membership survey, along with our more general membership and meeting
attendance data, suggested a clear mandate to the ASHG Board of Directors (BOD).
At the spring board meeting, the BOD reviewed the membership survey data and the
overwhelming suggestion from members that individuals residing outside the
Americas provide valuable insight and scientific contributions to the society.
Yet, due to their status as “overseas affiliates” or “overseas trainees” these
individuals are not eligible for participation in society leadership, including
the BOD and ASHG standing committees.
To address these concerns, the BOD presents the following changes to the ASHG
By-Laws. These will be discussed and voted on by the ASHG membership at the 2007
Membership/Business Meeting in San Diego. We welcome your commentary at that
time (Friday, October 26, 2:30 pm, Convention Center, Hall H). If you are unable
to attend the annual meeting, any questions, comments or concerns about these
changes can be sent to jboughman@ashg.org or
kshaw@ashg.org by October 20, 2007.
ARTICLE II – MEMBERSHIP AND DUES
II. A. TYPES of MEMBERSHIPS
Any person residing in the Americas who is interested in research in human
genetics or in issues pertaining to human genetics is eligible for membership in
the Society upon election by the Board of Directors.
REGULAR membership shall be open to all eligible persons.
TRAINEE membership shall be open to postdoctoral fellows, residents and bona
fide students participating in degree-granting programs at institutions in the
Americas. No individual shall remain a Trainee member for longer than five years
without documentation of student, resident or postdoctoral fellow status.
EMERITUS membership shall be open to all persons who shall have retired from
their position or practice and shall have been a Regular member of the Society
for at least five years. Emeritus members shall be entitled to all membership
rights and benefits, but shall not be required to pay dues unless they choose to
subscribe to the Journal at a reduced rate set by the Board of Directors.
OVERSEAS affiliate membership shall be open to individuals residing outside of
the Americas, who upon annual payment of an amount set by the Board of Directors
shall be entitled to all membership rights and benefits except to hold elected
positions and to vote.
OVERSEAS TRAINEE affiliate membership shall be open to postdoctoral fellows,
residents and bona fide students participating in degree-granting programs at
institutions outside the Americas. No individual shall remain an Overseas
Trainee affiliate for longer than five years without documentation of student,
resident or postdoctoral fellow status.
SUSTAINING CORPORATE affiliation shall be open to organizations that support the
objectives and activities of the Society upon approval of the Board of
Directors.
TOP OF
PAGE
|
From
Members of the ASHG Board of Directors |
SNP-IT continues to help you get to know
members of your Board of Directors by sharing their
answers to questions both traditional and
unexpected.
|
Roderick R. McInnes, MD, PhD
Director, CIHR, Institute of Genetics
A moment from the ASHG Archives:
At the 1985 ASHG meeting, Frank Ruddle of
Yale University, working with Bill McGinnis
also at Yale, reported that they had
identified homeobox genes in the human
genome that were highly related to the Hox
genes in flies that McGinnis had recently
discovered. At that time, the idea that a
fly developmental gene would have a strongly
related counterpart in man (and mouse!), was
mind-boggling. To this day, I can picture
the DNA blots of Ruddle's on the screen at
the meeting, confirming the existence of
these fly-related genes. Nowadays, the
conservation of developmental genes
throughout evolution we take for granted.
Then, it was revolutionary. Within a few
years, a post-doc in the lab rushed in to
tell me that one of the genes she had found
in a screen for genes that were likely to be
important to the eye (even though we didn't
know what they did yet) was related to fly
homeobox genes. She asked, "Do you think
this is important?" The answer was easy, and
our subsequent work showed that this gene,
now called Chx10, is a significant regulator
of human eye formation." |
|
|
Michael Boehnke, PhD
Department of Biostatistics and Center
for Statistical Genetics, University of
Michigan
Research description:
Design and analysis of human gene mapping
studies of common multifactorial diseases,
association and linkage mapping,
applications to type 2 diabetes, bipolar
disorder, schizophrenia, and several eye
diseases.
Favorite mentors/people that have shaped
your career?
Kenneth Lange, my graduate advisor at
UCLA.
Any nuggets of advice for trainees/young
scientists?
Ask lots of people for advice, but in the
end, do what feels right to you.
|
|
|
Wylie Burke, MD, PhD
University of Washington School of
Medicine, Seattle
Research
description:
Evaluation
of ethical and policy implications of
genetics in medicine and public health.
If your
office was on fire, what one object would
you take with you?
Keys to my
car. (This scenario actually did arise in a
somewhat different form - what to grab on
the way out of the building in the middle of
an earthquake. I had the foresight to grab
my purse and thus didn't have to consider
how I would get home if the building fell on
my car keys. Of course, the building might
have fallen on my car...).
What would
you like ASHG members to know about you?
I am
intrigued by cross-disciplinary
conversation—nothing quite so scary or
interesting as researchers talking across
divides of technical language and
methodological assumptions.
Favorite science joke?
Not quite
a science joke, but something I heard in
grad school and have been laughing about
ever since: Final exam for PhD in
philosophy: "Explain the universe. Give
two examples."
Moment
you knew you'd be a scientist?
No single
moment.
Any
major "aha" moments that have marked your
career?
So many it
is hard to keep track, but probably not in
the sense you mean. The work I do is not
focused on discovery in the same way that
bench science is. But policy analysis is
full of surprising connections. In
particular, disputes, whether about
appropriateness/quality of methods,
interpretation of results, or judgments
about clinical applications, always reveal
interesting differences in values and
expectations.
Favorite mentors/people that have shaped
your career?
Arno
Motulsky, Judy Hall, Linda Rosenstock
[former colleague, now Dean of School of
Public Health, UCLA].
Any
nuggets of advice for trainees/young
scientists?
My advice is the usual "follow your
instincts; do what you are passionate
about..." but I would add that it is
essential to learn how to critique your own
thinking as you go: "What am I missing?
What is the alternative explanation?"
TOP OF PAGE
|
|
Geneticist-Educator Network
of Alliances (GENA) Project: Looking
for Next Cohort of Geneticists |
-Kenna Mills Shaw, ASHG Director of Education
In October 2006, ASHG was awarded a $1.1M grant from the National Science
Foundation (NSF) to direct a program called the
Geneticist-Educator Network of
Alliances (GENA) Project. This program is a unique component of the Division of
Undergraduate Education at NSF and is specifically part of the Math and Science
Partnership program (MSP). The goal of the MSP program is to involve active
scientists in K-12 education. While the data from the first several cohorts of
MSP programs suggest that the involvement of scientists in professional
development experiences for K-12 teachers ultimately has a positive impact on
student achievement, a study from the University of Maryland also demonstrated
that faculty were being actively discouraged from taking part in MSP-supported
programs because participation was not considered an essential part of their
required duties as faculty members.
Thus, NSF specifically requested proposals for programs that might help
institutions of higher learning better support faculty involvement in such
professional development experiences for K-12 science, technology, engineering
and mathematics teachers, particularly for those faculty members who will
eventually undergo the review process for promotion and tenure.
The GENA program was the only grant awarded funding to address this issue. The
premise: because 1) involvement in a disciplinary society is encouraged (if not
required) for faculty in many promotion and tenure guidelines, and 2)
participation in a national outreach effort (as opposed to a local effort) is
viewed favorably in the promotion or tenure review process, then a systemic
program established, coordinated and supported by a large disciplinary society
could provide the opportunity and infrastructure to not only enhance MSP-type
programs by faculty members’ participation but to assist them in their
professional advancement.
The GENA Project, described in detail online, has just
completed its first year. From July 31 through August 2, 2007, 13 ASHG and GSA
members took part in a 3-day GENA workshop in Bethesda, Maryland, and have begun
a year-long partnership with a teacher in their area. During the next year,
these 13 individuals will work with their educator partners to develop engaging,
inquiry-centered curricula for high school students. These curricula will be
reviewed, evaluated and disseminated so that others across the country can
utilize the ideas and information.

Over the next 2 years we hope to train 80 more scientists as part of this
program. In 2008, we will host summer workshops in Minneapolis, Minnesota, and
Montclair, New Jersey. In 2009, the workshops will likely be held in San
Francisco, California, and Huntsville, Alabama.
If you are a tenure track professor who might be interested in this program,
please review our materials on the GENA Web site and
complete an application.
All applications for the 2008 cohorts are due by October 15, 2007. If you have
questions about the program, please contact Kenna Shaw, PI:
kshaw@ashg.org
TOP OF
PAGE
|
Need Advice or Guidance
on Professional Issues? |
Dear Genie says…
Your search has ended. Send your questions to Dear
Genie at
genie@ashg.org and look for answers,
advice, insights, and guidance in future issues of
SNP-IT.
|
Featured Question:
Dear Genie,
I finally see the light at the end of the
tunnel. My most recent manuscript was just
accepted at The American Journal of Human
Genetics (AJHG) and my dissertation
committee told me at my last meeting that
once I had an additional publication, I
could begin writing my thesis. As I begin
that process, I also have started to think
more concretely about my next steps. My
advisor has already been sending me
references from other labs that she thinks I
might find interesting for a post-doc. Yet,
I have been thinking at broadening my
experience a bit and looking into performing
research in Drosophila or zebrafish so I can
have more experience with model organisms.
I discussed this with a member of my
dissertation committee members who told me
that if I want a career in human genetics, I
would need to pursue human genetics as a
postdoc. My hope was that I could use my
postdoctoral fellowship to help make that
decision. What should I do?
Sincerely,
Flies, Fish or Folks?
|
 |
|
Genie's Response:
Dear F3,
It sounds like you are worried, at least in
part, about disappointing your thesis
advisor. While she may have been trying to
seed your thinking about your future
training, her focus on human genetics
laboratories are likely reflective of a) the
fact that you haven’t told her that you are
interested in pursuing another track and/or
b) her own comfort level with specific
advisors and laboratories. Less likely is
her focus based on a negative perception of
other types of postdoctoral experiences. My
first suggestion would be to talk openly
with your advisor about these concerns and
your interest in other fields.
|
"Use the ASHG annual meeting to
meet individuals you can enlist as
resources,
as mentors and as sounding
boards..." |
My second suggestion is to take a faculty
member’s opinion for what it’s worth—a
single point of view. It may not necessarily
be an accurate representation of the current
climate. While certainly there are fields
that would be more difficult to “break back
into,” this is not generally the case. If
you are interested in direct clinical
applications, in biochemical, molecular or
cytogenetics, the path is clear and that
includes postdoc training in an accredited
program. If your goal is focused in the
basic or translational research lab, then
ask yourself and several mentors about
conceptual issues also: developmental
genetics, cardiovascular, neuroscience, and
consider labs looking at the issue from
different perspectives, including from the
point of view of different model organisms.
This year the ASHG Annual Meeting includes
invited talks and many submitted abstracts
utilizing model organisms to provide useful
insight into human genes, health and
disease. Be opportunistic and use the
meeting to meet individuals you can enlist
as resources, as mentors and as sounding
boards for your concerns. Many of them have
just recently been in your shoes and can
provide you valuable advice.
The most important aspect of your
postdoctoral training will be to determine
as soon as possible what area you would like
to pursue in your own lab and start building
up your portfolio of techniques, reagents
and collaborations to assist you on that
path. Your postdoctoral training is an ideal
time to either switch fields completely or
seek training complementary to what you have
had as a graduate student. Either way,
learning new skills, techniques and even
entire fields will only enable you to pursue
a wider variety of research tracks in the
future.
Looking forward to reading your AJHG
paper,
Genie
|
Dear Genie welcomes your questions and will read
them all, but even a genie can’t promise to respond
to every one. Questions selected for SNP-IT
may be edited for length and style.
TOP OF
PAGE
|
New Member Benefit: ASHG
Forums |
Straight from the Membership Survey
-Kenna Mills Shaw, ASHG Director of Education
 |
We hope that you have been keeping up with the changes that have already been
implemented directly as a result of your comments from the ASHG membership
survey. The presence of this electronic newsletter, expansion of the mission of
the Professional Development Committee, and the proposed changes to the
ASHG
By-Laws regarding international
members are all a direct result of member commentary. Another new program that
we have begun in response to your comments is the ASHG/GSA Member Forums.
Instead of having members sign up for specific topic-based listserves, we have
created a set of electronic forums that members can reach through the ASHG Web
site. Not only are older topics archived so messages can be searched later, but
members can initiate new forum topics on a variety of issues ranging from job
searches to textbook reviews. Recently ASHG members received an e-mail informing
them of how to log-in and access these forums. This article serves as both a
reminder and encouragement to our members to engage themselves and their
colleagues in these forums.
The success of the ASHG forums will be determined and measured by our members.
We will do whatever we can to provide guidance and opportunities for use, but
only our members can provide the content and interaction needed for this new
resource to have traction in our community.
There are many broad categories including professional development, mentoring,
education, and policy. If you are specifically interested in one of these areas,
click on the appropriate topic. From here, you can post a new topic, read
previous postings, or comment on what others have already written. You can even
post “polls” to gauge your colleagues interest on a certain topic. If you are
interested in moderating a specific topic and being responsible for generating
and soliciting content, please contact us.
Visit: http://www.ashg.org/forum/, enter your username and password, and start
interacting with your colleagues! If you have questions, please do not hesitate
to contact the ASHG Education Office at kshaw@ashg.org.
TOP OF
PAGE
|
ASHG Forums Quiz: Get Your
T-Shirt On! |
Still
wish you could get your hands on an AJHG
T-shirt? Here’s the latest opportunity to cash in
and be the envy of all your colleagues. The first
three individuals to send in their answers to the
following “ASHG Forums Quiz” will receive a free
AJHG T-shirt. Please fax your answers to
301-634-7079 or e-mail them to Kenna Shaw at
kshaw@ashg.org
along with your T-shirt size and mailing address.
-
Participation in these forums is limited to
members from which two societies?
-
Name three different topics that are currently
available for discussion.
-
We have posted some information on the forums
about ASHG and the ASHG 57th Annual Meeting. Can
you find the following information by exploring
different forums topics?
-
How many abstracts were submitted for the
Annual Meeting as of the abstract deadline
(June 7, 2007)?
-
What is the new name of the ASHG Mentor
Network?
-
What was the topic of the first press
release posted on the Forums?
-
Please post at least one reply or one
question/comment in one of the forums and let us
know what topic you have posted to.
TOP OF
PAGE
|
The Arrival of WikiGenetics |
-Sharon F. Terry, President and CEO, The Genetic
Alliance
If you are even vaguely familiar with looking up
information using the Internet, you have probably
heard of or come across a Web site called Wikipedia.
This online encyclopedia is different from an
electronic version of the encyclopedia you might
have on your home bookshelf. Each article can be
modified by any user. Users can write, edit, or
amend wherever they wish. The result, if done with
careful oversight, is an incredibly information rich
electronic resource. The open-access nature of
Wikipedia has earned it some strong criticism. The
lack of peer review has allowed disreputable
individuals to erase, change, or otherwise add
erroneous information to the electronic compilation.
For that reason, many educational institutions have
begun policies that prohibit students from using
Wikipedia sources for their research papers.
Nonetheless, the Wikipedia format has been highly
successful in gaining a large readership. Members of
the human genetics community, in this case
spearheaded by the Genetic Alliance, want to
capitalize on the popularity and collaborative
nature of the Wiki format while simultaneously
ensuring quality and accuracy. Thus, they are in the
initial stages of establishing a wiki devoted to
human genetics for the lay public. The first steps
were to set up an advisory board and an editorial
board, both of which are comprised of experts in a
variety of topics areas in human genetics.
While the Genetic Alliance has staff support to
accomplish many of the core tasks involved with
generation of the wiki itself, we know that many
ASHG members are interested in becoming more
involved in outreach to the lay public. If you are
indeed interested in being a contributor to
WikiGenetics (writing a brief article or series of
articles) or in editing the articles of others,
please contact Sharon Terry at
sterry@geneticalliance.org for more information
and to join this effort.
TOP OF
PAGE
|
Take Advantage of What the
National Society of Genetic Counselors
Offers to All Geneticists! |
A
Note from One of Our “Sister” Societies
-Julie McCarrier, MS
October is a very busy month for meetings in human
genetics. The National Society of Genetic
Counselors (NSGC) meeting will be held in Kansas
City, October 11–16. The annual ASHG meeting
will be held in San Diego, October 24–27.
The Early Bird registration deadline for the NSGC
Annual Education Conference (AEC) was July 20.
“Survival Skills for the 21st Century: How to Shape Your Future as a
Genetic Counselor” is the topic of the short course,
slated for October 11–12. This year’s short course
focuses on business skills, leadership development,
conflict resolution, negotiation, and the expanding
roles of genetic counselors.
The main portion of the AEC takes place from October
12–16, and is comprised of plenary sessions and
educational breakout sessions that will meet the
educational needs of all genetics professionals.
Goals of the AEC are to ensure that participants
understand and incorporate new technologies, genetic
testing and research results into practice; to
describe recent developments in medical genetics and
genetic counseling, including therapeutic options,
disease management and diagnosis; and to identify
emerging areas of social, legal, and ethical
conflicts.
The concurrent paper sessions are categorized into
the following topics: genetic testing, professional
issues, pre- and perinatal, education,
counseling/psychosocial issues, adult cancer, and
professional issues.
The AEC is designed to meet the needs of providers
of traditional and non-traditional genetic
counseling, including those genetic counselors,
medical geneticists, and PhDs working in prenatal,
pediatric, cancer, public health, research,
laboratory and industry niches.
Highlights of the 2007 AEC include a panel with
topics including “Our Back Pages: The Origins of
Genetic Counseling and Medical Genetics,” and
“Domesticating Humans: Technical Solutions and
Ethical Problems in Early Medical Genetics.” The
2007 Dr. Beverly Rollnick Memorial Lecture will be
given by Kim Peek, who was the inspiration for the
movie, “Rainman,” and his father, Fran Peek.
There is sure to be something for everyone in
attendance at the 2007 Educational Breakout
Sessions. Examples of breakout sessions include:
-
(Mis)Understanding Probabilistic Information
-
CGH Microarrays: Practical Advice for Clinical
Application and Interpretation
-
Connective Tissue Disorders: Navigating the
Clinical Diagnosis and Counseling Maze
-
The Role of the Genetic Counselor in Fetal
Therapy/Intervention Clinics
-
Common Extra-colonic and Extra-endometrial
Cancers in Lynch Syndrome: Incidence,
Heterogeneity and Screening
-
The Evolution/Creationism Debate: Ways of
Thinking and Talking About It
This year a CD-ROM with speaker presentations is
available for purchase―a nice option if you cannot
come to Kansas City. The NSGC and ASHG have a lot of
offer all genetics professionals. We encourage
people to support both organizations with
membership. For more information about the NSGC
meetings, services, and membership information,
please visit
www.nsgc.org
TOP OF
PAGE
|
CORN Genetics: Regional
Genetics Networks |
-Kenna Mills Shaw, ASHG Director of
Education
What does CORN have to do with genetics? If
your answer is the work of Barbara McClintock for which she was awarded a Nobel
Prize in Physiology or Medicine in 1983, most geneticists would agree with you.
However, just two years after her theories of genetic control were recognized by
the Nobel committee, another CORN became important in human genetics: the
Council of Regional Networks (CORN) for Genetic Services. CORN served to
coordinate the work of 10 regional networks representing all 50 states, the
District of Columbia, Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands, national sickle cell
disease programs and genetic support groups. These networks, funded in part by
the United States Department of Health and Human Services, Health Resources and
Services Administration (HRSA) Genetic Services Branch, promote education and
awareness of genetic disorders, answer inquiries regarding genetics and
counseling services, share resources, and facilitate communication between
genetics professionals and consumers.
Results from the ASHG
membership survey revealed that many members are
involved in these regional networks or have
participated in regional meetings (through the
official regional genetics network in their area) or
more informal local meetings. These members
suggested that other ASHG members might benefit from
the ability to learn more about these and other
regional initiatives.
Therefore, we are asking
all ASHG members to inform us about regional
genetics activities that are ongoing in your area.
For example, each year, human geneticists from
Vancouver and Seattle have a-one day workshop that
allows a collegial, informal interchange of ideas, a
nonthreatening environment for trainees to present,
and a perfect venue for establishing productive
collaborations.
If you are involved in
regional activities and see a role for ASHG in those
activities, please let us know your ideas. While we
are still exploring the full range of possibilities,
we hope that learning more about these regional
exchanges will better inform future society
initiatives.
Links to more information on the
Regional Genetics Network in your area:
GeNeS-R-US (Genetic
and Newborn
Screening
Resource
Center of the
United
States).
Heartland Genetics and Newborn Screening Collaborative
Arkansas, Iowa, Kansas, Missouri, North Dakota, Nebraska, Oklahoma, and South
Dakota.
Mid-Atlantic Regional Human Genetics Network
Pennsylvania; New Jersey; Delaware; Maryland; Washington, DC; West Virginia;
and
Virginia.
Mountain States Genetics Network
MoStGeNe is made up of genetic service providers and consumers from six Rocky
Mountain states: Arizona, Colorado, Montana, New Mexico, Utah, and Wyoming.
NERGG
New England Regional Genetics Group: Maine, Vermont, New Hampshire,
Massachusetts, Rhode Island, and Connecticut.
PacNoRGG
Pacific Northwest Regional Genetics Group: Washington, Oregon, Idaho, and Alaska.
PSRGN
Pacific Southwest Regional Genetics Group: California, Nevada, and Hawaii.
SERGG
Southeastern Regional Genetics Group: Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Louisiana,
Mississippi, North Carolina, Puerto Rico, South Carolina, Tennessee, and the
Virgin Islands.
TOP OF
PAGE
|
Future Scientists Looking
for Mentors |
-Kenna Mills Shaw, ASHG Director of Education
Each year ASHG receives requests from high school
students looking for possible mentors for summer
internships. In rare cases we have been able to
match students with mentors, but we have not had a
systematic way of locating a local research mentor
for every student.
Many of us had our first laboratory experience as a
high school student. From that moment, we were
“hooked.” Now is your opportunity to offer another
generation that same experience. If you would be
willing to serve as a mentor in the future for a
summer research student,
please provide your information online.
This does not indicate a commitment to host a
student, just a willingness to be contacted if a
student in your area comes directly to ASHG
requesting assistance finding a local laboratory.
We thank you in advance for your assistance, and we
look forward to hearing from our members who already
host summer students so we can encourage our
colleagues to participate in such an important
outreach program for students.
TOP OF
PAGE

SNP-IT is published online four times a year,
in February, May, August and November. Copyright by
The American Society of Human Genetics.
Please direct all SNP-IT inquiries to Kenna
Mills Shaw, ASHG Director of Education, at
kshaw@ashg.org
For Society information, please
contact the ASHG Administrative Office, 9650
Rockville Pike, Bethesda, MD 20814-3998. Telephone:
301-634-7300; fax: 301-634-7090,
society@ashg.org
or visit ASHG on the Web:
www.ashg.org |